Why Do Wines Taste Different?

Engraving of two glasses of red wine, one pale and one almost black, on an open book before a vineyard window

Why Do Wines Taste Different?

Journal · How to Choose a Wine · Chapter 3

This is the written companion to Chapter 3 of our video series How to Choose a Wine.


Same juice, two drinks

Two red wines: one so pale you can read through it, the other almost black, yet both are fermented grape juice made in much the same way. The grape, the place and the winemaker's hand make the difference, and once you know what each does, "Pinot Noir", "Chablis" or "aged in oak" predict a style.


The grape

Most of what makes a red wine red lives in the skin. Almost all grape juice is pale; red wine soaks it on the skins, like tea brewed with the leaves. Colour comes from pigments called anthocyanins; tannin, the drying grip, from skins and seeds. Small, thick-skinned berries such as Cabernet Sauvignon or Syrah give deep colour and firm tannin. Pinot Noir has thin skins and fewer pigments, so its wines are paler and silkier.

Four aroma families you can predict

Methoxypyrazines smell of green pepper and cut grass, typical of Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc and Sauvignon Blanc. In red wine we notice them at around fifteen billionths of a gram per litre. They break down as grapes ripen in warmth, so a green note in a Cabernet often points to a cool year, or early picking.

Terpenes give rose, lychee and orange blossom. They dominate Muscat and Gewürztraminer and lift Riesling. Many sit in the grape bound to sugar, without smell, and are freed slowly: one reason a Riesling keeps changing in the bottle.

Rotundone, the very molecule of black pepper, was identified in Australian Shiraz in 2008 and is strongest in Syrah from cool, damp seasons. About one person in five cannot smell it.

Thiols give passion fruit and grapefruit, typical of Sauvignon Blanc. The grape locks them inside odourless molecules and yeast frees them during fermentation, like a key in a sealed envelope: the grape holds it, the cellar opens it.


The place: climate

Ripening is a trade between sugar and acid. Sunshine becomes sugar in the berry, and yeast turns sugar into alcohol: more warmth, more alcohol and body. Acid moves the other way. The grape holds two main acids, tartaric and malic; malic acid, the sharp acid of green apples, is burned by the ripening berry as fuel, and heat speeds the loss, like a fire burning faster in a draught. So wines from warm places and hot years tend to taste softer, and wines from cool places brisker.

That is why growers in warm regions prize cool nights and higher slopes, which slow ripening, and why latitude shows in the glass. Chablis, at the cool northern edge of Burgundy, gives a taut, citrus Chardonnay; in a warm valley, the same grape tends towards tropical fruit, more alcohol and a rounder feel. Heat shifts the fruit too: red fruit from cool places, black fruit and plum from warm ones, jammy notes in very hot years.

On Saturday, around €80, with roast chicken and morels, choose the cool side: a Côte de Beaune red, or a Côte d'Or white with the acidity to carry a creamy sauce.


The place: soil

Soil, honestly, acts mostly through water. Limestone rubble or gravel lets the rain through, a sieve rather than a sponge. Under mild water stress, the vine slows its leafy growth and puts its energy into the fruit; berries stay small, with more skin for each drop of juice, so more colour, tannin and flavour per litre. In a study of three Greek vineyards over one season, the driest soil gave smaller berries and wines with more colour, alcohol and tannin; vines over a permanent water table gave lighter wines.

Deep, rich, wet soil does the opposite: a vigorous vine, big berries, more dilute wine. Hence the thin soils over limestone of the great Burgundy slopes, and regional wines from the deeper land below.

And minerality?

You are not tasting rock: the minerals a vine takes up are far too faint for the tongue. Research links the impression to brisk acidity, restrained fruit and sulphur compounds formed in the cellar, which smell of struck flint. It describes a style, not a soil: cool-climate whites with high acidity, such as Chablis, Sancerre or dry Riesling.


The hand

Four cellar decisions change the taste most.

Whole bunch

Fermenting with the stems starts part of the fermentation inside unbroken berries, which tends to give lifted, floral, spicy aromas. The stems add tannin and slightly lower the acidity; in Pinot Noir trials, whole-bunch wines came out firmer, sometimes more vegetal, like a herb infusion made with the stalks. Made with half whole bunches, the same Pinot Noir tends towards rose, pepper and a firmer finish.

Malolactic fermentation

Bacteria can turn sharp malic acid into softer lactic acid, the acid of yoghurt. Malic acid carries two acid groups, lactic only one, so the wine tastes less sharp, and a by-product, diacetyl, smells of butter. Almost all reds go through it, and most Côte d'Or Chardonnay; most Sauvignon Blanc is kept from it.

Oak and lees

A new barrel gives vanillin, the molecule of vanilla, and oak lactones, which smell of coconut. American oak tends to give more coconut, French oak finer spice; a heavier toast, more smoke and spice. Each refill gives less, like a spice jar opened again and again. On its lees, the deposit of dead yeast, a wine takes up proteins and sugars from the yeast walls: a creamier texture, aromas of bread. Non-vintage Champagne rests at least twelve months on its lees in the bottle.


Six questions to forecast the taste

1 · The grape

What is the grape, written or implied?

Thin skins (Pinot Noir, Gamay) for silk and red fruit; thick skins (Cabernet, Syrah, Nebbiolo) for grip. Midweek, around €25, with tomato sauce, a low-tannin, bright Beaujolais cru beats a firm Cabernet.

2 · The climate

How warm is the place?

Cool for freshness: Chablis, Sancerre, the Mosel, the Côte d'Or. Warm for ripeness and body: the southern Rhône, much of Spain, South Australia.

3 · The alcohol

What does the alcohol say?

Two degrees make a different wine: lighter and brisker at 12.5%, fuller and softer at 14.5%.

4 · The oak

Was it aged in oak, and how much was new?

"Élevé en fût de chêne" means some wood; much new oak, vanilla and toast. For a client abroad, around €150, a classic oaked Côte de Beaune white or red Bordeaux is the safest forecast.

5 · The cellar

Lees and malolactic, or neither?

Rounder, creamier whites, like Meursault, carry Saturday's morels; taut, citrus whites, like Chablis, suit oysters better.

6 · The structure

Which grape and place build a wine to last?

For a newborn, around €300 in all: firm tannin or high acidity (Nebbiolo, Cabernet Sauvignon, grand cru Pinot Noir, Riesling, Chenin Blanc). Structure carries a wine through eighteen years.


Our view: never choose by the grape alone

Pinot Noir from a cool limestone slope and Pinot Noir from a hot, fertile valley share a name, and little else. The place and the hand weigh as much as the grape: read all three, and the bottle will rarely surprise you.

Three things to keep: the grape sets the range; climate sets the balance of sugar and acid, and soil works through water; the winemaker can move a wine a long way within that range.


Ask your concierge

For a forecast on a particular bottle, Speak to your concierge, or use the WhatsApp button on the site.

Earlier in the series: Chapter 1, six questions before buying, and Chapter 2, reading a wine label.

Next in the series: Chapter 4, Does the Vintage Really Matter?