How to Choose a Good Wine: 6 Questions to Ask Before Buying
Journal · How to Choose a Wine · Chapter 1
This is the written companion to Chapter 1 of our video series How to Choose a Wine. Most people choose by price, a known name or the prettiest label. A wine merchant asks six questions instead, and two hundred bottles become three or four.
There is no best wine
"Which wine is the best?" has no answer. The same bottle can be perfect at one table and a waste of money at another. There is only the best wine for a purpose.
Four situations run through this guide: a midweek dinner at a friend's (about €25), a Saturday dinner for friends who love wine (about €80 a bottle), a present for an important client abroad (about €150), and bottles for a newborn to open at eighteen (about €300 in all).
1. What is this bottle for?
To drink, to give, to keep or to learn. Almost everyone who comes to us has one of seven intentions: a gift, the codes of a table, a dish, a first step into wine, deeper knowledge, good value or a collection.
Each asks something different. A gift must be right on the day someone else opens it. A pairing must suit the plate, and reputation adds nothing to it. A collection must last, and prove where it has been. Midweek and Saturday are about drinking with a dish, the client's bottle is a gift and a matter of codes, the newborn's bottles are for keeping.
2. Who will drink it?
We do not all perceive wine the same way. Sensitivity to bitterness, for example, varies from person to person, partly because of our genes. A very dry, firm or aged wine that delights an expert can puzzle a newcomer.
Midweek calls for an open, easy wine; Saturday's friends will notice character more than a famous name; your client is safer with a classic style; for the newborn, only the ability to last counts.
3. What will it be served with?
Tannin and protein
Tannin, the drying grip of red wine, binds to the proteins in your saliva. That is why tannic reds feel softer with red meat or hard cheese: the protein and fat give the tannin something else to hold.
Acidity meets acidity
Acidity cuts through richness, and an acidic dish (lemon, tomato) needs a wine at least as fresh, or the wine tastes flat.
Midweek spaghetti with tomato sauce therefore calls for freshness: a juicy red from a cool region, or a crisp white. Saturday's roast chicken with morels has little tannin and real depth: a red or white Burgundy fits it beautifully.
4. When will it be opened?
Wine keeps changing in the bottle. Most wines are made to be enjoyed within a few years; a smaller number develop over decades, as their tannins soften and their aromas move from fresh fruit towards leather, forest floor or honey.
What lets a wine last is a combination: acidity, tannin and related compounds, sometimes sugar or extra alcohol (as in sweet and fortified wines), then a sound cork and cool, dark, steady storage. Take one away and the clock runs faster. Open an age-worthy wine too early and you pay for potential you never taste.
When we visit domaines in Burgundy, growers often give us the same rule of thumb: regional wines are usually made to be enjoyed young, premier crus tend to reach their best between five and ten years, and grand crus often need seven to fifteen years to show their full potential.
At €80, that is the real trap: a premier cru from a recent great vintage can still be tight. For the newborn, eighteen years leaves only wines built to wait (grand cru Burgundy or great Bordeaux from a strong year, vintage Port, Sauternes, the finest Rieslings), ideally in magnum, since wine ages more slowly in a large bottle. Or a vintage Cognac or Armagnac from the year of birth: a spirit stops ageing once bottled.
5. What is your budget?
Every budget has excellent wines, and price is a poor guide to taste, because it measures two things.
The first is cost: lower yields, picking by hand, time in the cellar, oak. A new French oak barrel costs around €1,200 and a Burgundy barrel fills about 300 bottles, so the wood alone adds about €4 a bottle.
The second is land and scarcity. In 2025, premier cru Chardonnay vineyards in the Côte d'Or sold for an average of €2.7 million a hectare. That is in the price of the bottle, not in its taste.
So the best value often lies where cost is high but fame is low: a great producer's wine from a modest appellation, the lesser-known neighbour of a famous village, a lighter vintage from an excellent estate. At €25, choose a very good producer over the cheapest famous name. Above that, choose what you pay for: the producer, rank or age at €80, recognition at €150, the right year and proven provenance for the newborn.
6. What have you enjoyed before?
One wine you liked, and why, says more than ten adjectives. Otherwise, use plain words: fresh or round, light or rich, fruity or savoury. Your Saturday friends loved a silky, fragrant red last time: that points to Pinot Noir, and to Burgundy. For your client, ask someone who knows them.
Four situations, several right answers
Midweek · about €25
A bottle that fits the evening
A Beaujolais cru from a good grower, a red or white regional Bourgogne, or a crisp Bourgogne Aligoté.
Saturday · about €80 a bottle
Ready for the morels
A village wine from a top Côte d'Or producer, a premier cru from a lighter, already open vintage, or a well-kept ten-year-old red Burgundy.
The client · about €150
A classic, with a card
A vintage Champagne from a great house for a celebration, or a premier cru from a village whose name travels, if your client knows wine. Add a short card saying when to open it.
The newborn · about €300 in all
Built to wait eighteen years
A magnum of long-lived red from a strong vintage, two bottles of grand cru Burgundy or great Bordeaux, or vintage Port from a declared year, with a clear storage record, kept lying down, cool and dark.
Four mistakes we see every week
Choosing by price alone, which reflects cost and demand. By fame alone: a famous label opened too young, or from a difficult year, can disappoint. By vintage alone: a great year in one region can be ordinary in another. By the label's design or a medal sticker, which speak of marketing more than wine.
Our view: pay for what you will taste. Potential you will never wait for, a name nobody at the table will notice, a rarity that adds nothing to the dish: that is money spent on someone else's purpose.
The six questions to keep
Question 1
What is it for?
Drink, give, keep or learn.
Question 2
Who will drink it?
Tastes, culture, experience.
Question 3
What will it be served with?
Tannin, acidity, the plate.
Question 4
When will it be opened?
Tonight, soon or in twenty years.
Question 5
What is the budget?
Cost, or fame and scarcity?
Question 6
What have you enjoyed before?
One wine you liked, and why.
Ask the Concierge
Tell us the purpose, the people, the dish, the timing and the budget, and we will suggest a few bottles, and why. Speak to your concierge, or use the WhatsApp button on the site.
Next in the series: how to read a wine label, and the clues that really matter.