Does the Vintage Really Matter?

Engraving of a Burgundy vineyard at night in spring, lit by rows of small frost candles

Does the Vintage Really Matter?

Journal · How to Choose a Wine · Chapter 4

This is the written companion to Chapter 4 of our video series How to Choose a Wine.


Three nights in April

April 2021. For three nights, Burgundy's vineyards glowed with small fires and candles lit between the rows: growers were fighting a frost, and by the harvest the region had lost about half of its crop. The year on a label records exactly that: the one line the producer does not choose. The vineyard, grape and cellar stay; the weather is new every year. How much should it change the bottle you choose?


What the weather does to a grape

Frost

In spring, the vine's new shoots carry that year's flower clusters. A few degrees below zero after the buds open, and they freeze and die, like a garden after a late frost: the plants live, this year's blossom is gone. Spare buds carry fewer, smaller bunches that ripen later and less evenly, so frost mostly cuts quantity. In April 2021, parts of Nuits-Saint-Georges fell to about seven degrees below zero; Chardonnay, which buds earlier, suffered most.

Hail

Hail is local and brutal: a ten-minute storm can strip one village and spare the next. Hailstones split berries, which invite rot, and if they reach the vat, even a few can leave the musty note growers call the hail taste. Sorting berry by berry is the only defence. Beaune, Pommard and Volnay were hit in 2012, 2013 and 2014.

Rain at harvest

Ripe berries take up water and swell, so their sugar, colour and flavour are diluted, like a soup watered just before serving. Thin skins split, and warm, damp days invite grey rot: Pinot Noir is the most exposed.

Heatwaves

In one Australian study, two weeks above 40 °C cut photosynthesis by about a third and halved the rate of ripening in exposed bunches, while sunburnt berries shrivelled. Acidity falls, sugar concentrates as water is lost, and the wine can taste heavy and cooked.

A great year needs steady warmth, enough water and a dry, sunny September, so that sugar, colour and tannin ripen together while the acidity stays: rarer than marketing suggests.


Where the year matters most

The year matters most where the climate sits on the edge. In a cool region, grapes only just ripen in an average year, like a runner who just makes the train: one wet week, or a little more warmth, and the wine changes character. Burgundy, Champagne, the Loire, Germany and, to a degree, Bordeaux sit near that edge. In much of California, South Australia or southern Spain, sunshine is more reliable, and the producer and site usually matter more.

Some regions build this into their rules: most Champagne blends years to smooth out the weather, vintage Champagne is made only in strong years, and vintage Port is declared a few times a decade. Whites and reds can also part ways: a cool, late season may be hard on Pinot Noir yet give Chardonnay bright acidity.

The producer or the year?

In a great year, nearly everyone makes good wine; in a difficult one, the gap between producers widens, because hard years test the work. The grower who spotted mildew early, sprayed at the right moment, picked on the right day and sorted out damaged berries makes a clean, balanced wine; the one who did not, a dilute or musty one, from the same vineyard and weather.

2024 was one of Burgundy's hardest seasons in memory: from January to May, more than twice the usual rain, and months of mildew. Hail on 1 May destroyed 60 to 100% of the crop in parts of Chablis. Yet careful producers made pure, fresh wines, lower in alcohol than usual, in small quantities.


What vintage charts miss

A chart gives one score to a whole region. It cannot see a hailstorm on one village, a frost that killed the low plots and spared the slope, or a producer who picked a week later. After a summer storm, half the bunches in a row can be scarred by hail while the parcel across the path is untouched: same appellation, same year, two very different wines.

A chart also mixes quality with readiness: a top score often means more tannin and concentration, and more years before the wine opens.

Lighter years

A cooler or more difficult season tends to give less concentration, softer tannin and brighter fruit, and wines ready sooner: a premier cru from a lighter year can be open at five, when one from a great year is still closed. When a light year is also large, prices tend to soften; when it is small, as 2021 was, scarcity can hold them up.


A warming climate

In Beaune, harvest dates have been recorded since 1354. From 1988 to 2018, the harvest began on average thirteen days earlier than over the six centuries before. The best Burgundy years used to be the warm ones, because ripeness was the struggle. Now heat brings its own risks (high alcohol, low acidity, cooked fruit), and some of the freshest wines come from years once thought too cool.

Warming does not end frost. A mild March wakes the buds earlier and exposes them longer to April's cold nights: a study of the 2021 frost found climate change made such an event about 50% more likely. And 2025 shows the new normal: two heatwaves, close to 40 °C in August, and in the Côte d'Or the first white grapes picked on 19 August. A Burgundy harvest in August was rare until this century.


Six questions before choosing by the year

1 · The region

Is the region marginal?

In Burgundy, Champagne, the Loire or Germany, look the year up; in warm, steady climates, the producer first. Midweek, around €25, the year matters least: a young regional wine from the latest good release.

2 · The weather

What happened that year, and where?

Frost, hail or rain may hit one village and spare the next; someone who visits the vineyards can tell you.

3 · The colour

Was it a good year for this colour?

Some years favour the whites, others the reds.

4 · The moment

When will it be opened?

Tonight, a lighter or older year. On Saturday, around €80, a trusted producer's premier cru from a lighter year often gives more than a great year opened ten years too soon. For a newborn, around €300 in all, the opposite: eighteen years need a strong year and a wine built to last.

5 · The producer

Who made it?

In a difficult year, choose only producers you know. For a client abroad, around €150, a widely praised year is part of the message: choose a region that succeeded that year.

6 · The quantity

What does the quantity say about the price?

A small year often costs more for the same quality. A generous, light year can be the best value in a decade.


Our view: the producer first, the year second

A great producer's lighter year is usually a better bottle than an ordinary producer's great one, often at a better price, and as summers grow hotter, the cool years deserve a second look.

Three things to keep: frost cuts quantity, hail and rain threaten quality, heat changes style; the year matters most in marginal regions; and in a difficult year, the producer matters more than ever.


Ask your concierge

For news of a year in a village, Speak to your concierge, or use the WhatsApp button on the site.

Earlier in the series: Chapter 1, six questions, Chapter 2, the label, and Chapter 3, the taste.

Next in the series: Chapter 5, How Much Should You Spend on Wine?