How Much Should You Spend on Wine?
Journal · How to Choose a Wine · Chapter 5
This is the written companion to Chapter 5 of our video series How to Choose a Wine.
Ten times better?
Two red Burgundies stand side by side, one at €25, the other at €250. The second is not ten times better, nor ten times the price by accident. A price covers what a wine costs to make, and what people pay for its land, name and rarity. The question is which euros reach the glass, and which pay for what nobody at the table will taste.
What it costs to make
A vine carrying fewer bunches ripens them more fully and concentrates its flavour, but each hectare gives less wine, like a fruit tree thinned in spring. Appellation law sets a ceiling: 42 hectolitres a hectare for a grand cru such as Clos de Vougeot, noticeably more for a regional Bourgogne. Many careful growers stay well below it: every litre left on the vine is a cost spread over fewer bottles.
Picking by hand lets a team leave rotten or unripe bunches in the row. A detailed 2022 costing put it at about €2 a bottle, roughly three times the cost of a machine. A new French oak barrel costs about €1,200. A Burgundy barrel holds 228 litres, about 300 bottles: some €4 of new wood in each.
Time costs money: eighteen months in barrel and a year in bottle tie up cash and space before the wine earns a cent. As with a cheese ripened two years instead of two months, the extra cost is the waiting itself. Packaging came to about €2.20 a bottle in that 2022 costing: a large share of a cheap wine's price, barely visible in an expensive one.
A meticulous grower spends more per bottle than a careless one, but rarely ten times more, so when a wine costs ten times its neighbour, the difference comes from elsewhere.
What it costs to own
That elsewhere is mostly land, scarcity and name. Safer, France's rural land agency, recorded an average of €2.7 million a hectare for premier cru Chardonnay vineyards in the Côte d'Or in 2025, against about €87,000 for all French appellation vineyards outside Champagne: more than thirty times less.
At its permitted 55 hectolitres, a hectare of premier cru Meursault gives about 7,000 bottles a year. Bought today, the interest alone, at 3%, would come to about €11 a bottle before a single vine is pruned. Most of this land is inherited, but a grower who could sell a hectare for millions will not price the wine as if it were worth thousands.
A grand cru often covers only a few hectares, wanted worldwide. Production cannot grow, so when demand rises only the price moves, like seats in a small theatre for a famous play. A famous name is also easy to recognise, resell and serve: a real safety, but not one you can taste.
Taxes vary hugely. In France in 2026, excise duty on a bottle of still wine is about 3 cents. In the United Kingdom, since February 2025, it is about £2.77 for a wine at 12.5% alcohol, with VAT on top in both. A £6 bottle in Britain is more than half tax, so trading up a few pounds there buys proportionally far more wine than in France.
The price curve
Put together, these costs draw a curve. At the bottom, fixed costs (glass, transport, tax, the shop's margin) are much the same for every bottle, so the first extra euros go almost entirely into the wine. Here, a little more changes the most.
In the middle, which in France we place roughly between €15 and €50, you pay for real choices: lower yields, hand picking, barrels, time, a good grower. Quality for each euro is often at its best here. Above that the curve flattens, and each extra euro buys more land, name and scarcity than taste. The step from €80 to €200 rarely tastes like the step from €10 to €40.
In a large 2008 study of more than 6,000 blind tastings, ordinary wine drinkers on average liked the more expensive wines slightly less; trained tasters did not. A high price often buys complexity, and complexity speaks most to experience.
Taste a grower's regional Bourgogne beside his premier cru from the same vintage: same pickers, same barrels, same care. The premier cru tends to be deeper and longer, rarely five times better, yet it can cost five times more, because the land under it does.
Five places where value hides
1. The great grower's modest wine
It often gets the same team, sorting and cellar as the grand cru: you pay for the work, not the land.
2. The less famous neighbour
Saint-Romain, Monthelie, Auxey-Duresses or Marsannay in the Côte d'Or; Rully, Mercurey and Givry in the Côte Chalonnaise; the Mâconnais for white. Similar grapes, often similar soils, a fraction of the land price.
3. A fine estate's lighter vintage
Often ready sooner, and usually priced below the famous years.
4. Regions out of fashion
German Riesling, the Loire, the Rhône beyond its most famous names, Spain, Portugal. Where demand has not caught up with quality, prices have not either.
5. Age already paid for
A merchant who has kept a wine well for ten years sells you time, which is expensive to buy any other way.
Where you buy
A supermarket's tight margins make it strong at the bottom of the curve, though bottles often stand upright under bright lights for weeks and the choice of growers is narrow. A specialist merchant may cost a little more at entry level, for trusted storage, growers you could not reach alone, and advice. Restaurants often charge two to three times what they paid; the multiple tends to shrink on expensive bottles, so the middle of the list is often better value than the cheapest line.
Five questions before you set a budget
Midweek · €25
Will anyone notice the difference?
If not, spend at the bottom of the middle: a good grower's regional wine or a Beaujolais cru.
Saturday · €80
Is the wine the centre of the evening?
Spend on the grower and the vineyard, not the label: a top producer's village wine, or a premier cru from a lighter vintage, with the morels.
The client · €150
Does the name carry the message?
Then reputation is worth paying for: a recognised appellation, or a vintage Champagne.
The newborn · €300
Must it last for decades?
Pay for structure and provenance, not fame alone: fewer bottles, better kept, perhaps one magnum rather than four bottles.
Restaurant or home
Where will it be opened?
In a restaurant, look to the middle of the list. At home, the same money buys a clear step up the curve.
Our view
Spend most where the price still pays for work, least where it only pays for fame. When fame is the point, for a gift or a bottle meant to last, choose it knowingly, never because a higher price promised a better wine.
Three things to keep
Only the cost reaches the glass
A price is cost plus land, scarcity and name. Value hides where cost is high and fame is low. Pay for a name only when the name is the message.
Ask the Concierge
If you have a budget and an occasion in mind, Speak to your concierge.
Earlier in the series: six questions before buying, reading a label, why wines taste different, the vintage.
Next in the series: when to open a bottle, and how to tell if it is ready.